Free property tax appeal review. Call 412-802-6666, text 412-855-5511, or send us a message.
Just bought a property and received a school district appeal notice? Do not ignore it.
Every year, Allegheny County school districts appeal the assessments of recently purchased homes and buildings, usually to raise the assessment toward the sale price. Owners call it the "Welcome to the Neighborhood Tax." Since 1997, Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick has handled more than 10,000 property tax appeals, including many school district appeals. Attorney Nicole Hauptman Amick leads that work and has helped thousands of property owners, with our whole team behind her.
Why Districts Appeal Recent Buyers
School districts usually have the highest millage of your three taxing bodies, so they gain the most from a higher assessment. A recent sale gives them an easy number to point to. The result can be two similar homes on the same street paying very different taxes simply because one sold recently.
What Happens When a School District Appeals
- The district files during the annual window, July 1 to September 1, for the next tax year. School districts, municipalities and the County can all appeal.
- You are notified. A taxing body that appeals must notify the owner. Then the County mails a hearing notice at least 14 days before a residential hearing, or 21 days before a commercial one.
- One hearing decides it. BPAAR holds one hearing per property, even when more than one party has appealed. If you also appealed, both appeals are heard together.
- The hearing is by phone. The appealing party goes first and must declare whether it is seeking Base Year or Current Market value. You or your lawyer can respond with your own evidence.
- The decision comes by mail, and any party can appeal it to the Court of Common Pleas within 30 days of the notice's mailing date.
Why You Should Not Ignore It
- The value can go up. BPAAR will increase, decrease or keep the assessment based on the evidence of value presented.
- The hearing goes forward without you. Owners are not required to attend, but if no one answers the district's evidence, the Board hears only one side.
- Withdrawing your own appeal does not stop theirs. If the district appealed, its hearing proceeds even if you withdraw.
- The cost repeats. A higher assessment raises your County, school and municipal taxes, not just the school bill, every year until the assessment changes again.
What to Do When the Notice Arrives
- Read the dates. Note the hearing date and time, and calendar the five-day deadline to give the County your phone number.
- Call us before you respond to the district. Do not answer questions about your purchase, renovations or financing until you get advice.
- Authorize your representative. If someone will appear for you, file the County's Appointment of Authorized Representative form so they can act for you and receive the decision.
- Plan your evidence. Under the Board's rules, evidence must be submitted to the County and served on the other parties at least two days before the hearing. We prepare and submit ours well ahead of that deadline. Evidence from an owner must be served on the taxing body, with proof of mailing. The County publishes school district solicitor contacts.
- Need a new date? Each party gets one postponement, requested in writing at least seven days before the hearing on the County's postponement form.
- Selling soon? If the property is sold before the hearing, the seller must tell the buyer, and the buyer must check the appeal's status and enter an appearance to take part.
How to Defend a School District Appeal
- Question the sale as evidence of value. Did you pay a premium in a bidding war? Did the price include furniture, equipment or seller concessions? Did you find defects after closing?
- Bring your own comparable sales. Recent arm's-length sales of your property and similar properties are the strongest evidence. Similar nearby properties selling for less can show that your purchase price was not typical.
- Choose the right standard. For a Base Year case, sales closer to January 1, 2012, in the same neighborhood are generally more relevant. We check both standards.
- Apply the CLR correctly. Any current market value shown at the hearing is multiplied by the Common Level Ratio. For appeals filed July 1 to September 1, 2026 (tax year 2027), the County's Common Level Ratio is 49.3%. A $400,000 value becomes about a $197,200 assessment, not $400,000.
- Check the district's comparables. We verify sale prices, dates and square footage against County records and look for sales that were not arm's length.
- Test the district's appraisal. The County says the weight given to an appraisal may be affected if the appraiser does not testify. If the district relies on a report without its author on the call, we point that out.
- Watch for assessment comparisons. The County says another property's assessment must be backed by proof that it reflects market value.
- Raise uniformity when the facts support it, such as nearby recent sales the district chose not to appeal.
Check where your assessment stands with our calculator →
Protect Yourself
- What you say can follow you. Statements at the first hearing can come up again if the case goes to the Board of Viewers.
- Do not volunteer information about renovations, appraisals or financing without advice.
- Ask us before agreeing to an inspection of your home by the district or its appraiser.
- Talk to a lawyer before answering written questions from a district.
- An attorney can appear for you, so in many cases you do not need to be on the call.
Pennsylvania and Allegheny County Rules You Should Know
- Districts have the right to appeal. The County allows the owner or any taxing body with a vested interest in the parcel, including the school district, the municipality or the County, to appeal.
- But not by targeting one property type. In 2017 the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a taxing body may not adopt a policy of appealing only one sub-class of property, such as only commercial properties (Valley Forge Towers Apartments N, L.P. v. Upper Merion Area School District). How that applies to selective appeals of recent buyers depends on the district's actual practice and the evidence.
- The Board decides on evidence. BPAAR will increase, decrease or keep the assessment based on the evidence of value presented.
- Hearings are by phone, with strict deadlines. Phone number at least five days before; one postponement per party, requested in writing at least seven days ahead.
- Evidence. Under the Board's rules, evidence must be submitted to the County and served on the other parties at least two days before the hearing. We prepare and submit ours well ahead of that deadline.
- Missing the hearing on your own appeal, without a timely postponement, means it is treated as withdrawn, and you lose further appeal rights for that year. A district's appeal goes forward either way.
- Second level. Any party can appeal the decision to the Court of Common Pleas, where it is heard by the Board of Viewers, within 30 days of the decision notice's mailing date. The County lists a nonrefundable filing fee of $135.25.
How We Defend These Appeals
- Authorization on file so we receive every notice and the decision.
- Free review of your notice, purchase and local sales. We tell you plainly whether defending makes financial sense.
- Our own evidence: comparable sales, condition evidence and, where it helps, an appraisal, served well ahead of the Board's two-day deadline.
- A review of the district's case: its comparables, its appraisal and whether its appraiser will testify.
- The BPAAR hearing, handled by us.
- The Board of Viewers, if needed, by us or by the district.
What About the Reassessment?
A countywide reassessment must be in place by June 30, 2032. Until then, school district appeals continue under the current system. Read our Reassessment Guide →
Related Cases We Handle
- Residential property tax appeals
- Commercial property appeals
- Allegheny County reassessment
- Complete property tax appeal guide
Official County Links
- Allegheny County: Assessment Appeals
- Real Estate Portal: look up, file and track appeals
- School District Solicitor Contacts, 2026 (PDF)
- Appointment of Authorized Representative form (PDF)
- Hearing Postponement Request form (PDF)
- Appeals Tip Sheet for 2027 (PDF)
County appeals information line: 412-350-4636, Option 2 (Monday to Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.). County rules last checked October 26, 2026.
Talk to a Property Tax Lawyer
Our school district defense work is led by Nicole Hauptman Amick, working with Noah Fardo and the rest of our team. We work closely as one team.
Call 412-802-6666, email nicole@pghfirm.com or Managing Partner Noah Fardo at npf@pghfirm.com. Prefer to text? Use 412-855-5511. More answers: Property Tax Appeal FAQ.
Fees are discussed and agreed in writing before we file. General information only, not legal advice. Deadlines and County procedures can change; confirm current rules before filing. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Defending School District Appeals
FAQ
No items found.
