Since 1997 | Your Pittsburgh Law Firm
Your Pittsburgh Law Firm
September 9, 2012

Status Update on Allegheny County Assessment Appeals

📚 Historical article. This post reflects the law and County procedures when it was written. Deadlines, the Common Level Ratio and hearing rules have changed, and a new countywide reassessment has been ordered.

Read the current 2027 Tax Appeal Guide →Reassessment Guide →

Originally published September 9, 2012. Updated October 2026.

In September 2012, formal hearings on 2013 assessment appeals were in full swing at the County Office Building in downtown Pittsburgh. Here is where things stood, and what we saw at the hearings.

Hearings at the Time

The Office of Property Assessments was under court order to decide all 2013 appeals by December 2012, and it appeared able to meet Judge R. Stanton Wettick’s deadline. The County used up to 50 contracted hearing officers a day, including some Saturdays, to hear up to 1,000 hearings a day.

Because of the volume, notice was a problem. Hearing notices usually went out at least ten days ahead, but many owners received them just days before their hearings. We urged owners waiting on a hearing to watch their mail and contact the Office of Property Assessments.

Two Mistakes Owners Kept Making

1. The wrong evidence. Many owners presented their neighbors’ assessments. That can seem relevant, but it is rarely persuasive. Hearing officers focus on the fair market value of your property, not how under-assessed your neighbors may be. Comparing assessments can sometimes help as part of a case, but it should never be the only basis. Comparable sales remain the strongest evidence for a reduction.

2. The wrong demeanor. Many owners got upset and took it out on the hearing officer. We saw hearing officers try to calm owners down, and in some cases the Sheriff was called to escort owners out. Hearing officers did not set your assessment. Their job is to recommend the correct market value to the Board. Anger directed at them usually hurts your case. Courtesy helps.

What Came After the Hearing

Decisions were expected within 60 to 120 days. An owner unhappy with the BPAAR decision could appeal to the Board of Viewers (BOV) of the Court of Common Pleas within 30 days of the mailing date on the Notice of Disposition.

We cautioned owners that, at the time, a BOV appeal could not be withdrawn without the taxing bodies’ consent, and that the BOV could keep, lower or raise the assessment. Owners needed a solid case before filing. Learn more in What Happens at the BOV Hearing.

What This Means for You Today

  • Bring evidence of your property’s market value, especially comparable sales.
  • Stay calm and respectful at your hearing.
  • Know your next-level appeal deadline and the risks before you file.
  • See our tax appeals FAQ and property tax appeals guide for current rules.

Talk to Us

Call 412-802-6666, text 412-855-5511, or send us a message for a free consultation.

Noah P. Fardo, Esq.

Managing Partner · Trial Lawyer

Noah Fardo is a Pittsburgh medical malpractice and personal injury trial lawyer who has represented injured patients, accident victims and their families since 1999.

Request a Free Consultation

Shawn T. Flaherty, Esq., founding partner, Flaherty Fardo Rogel & Amick
Shawn T. Flaherty, Esq.
Founding Partner | Personal Injury & Truck Accident Attorney
Thank you for your submission. We try to respond promptly, often within hours. If you need immediate assistance, you can try texting 412.855.5511. Be in touch shortly.

Thank you,
‍Noah Paul Fardo
Managing Partner
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.