If your property is over-assessed today, appeal now. Do not wait for the reassessment to fix it. That was the clear answer from our attorneys on a recent episode of our podcast, I Strenuously Object. Here is why, and when waiting does make sense.
The court gave Allegheny County until June 30, 2032, to put new values in place. It may finish sooner, but no one knows when new values will reach tax bills. Until they do, every bill uses your current assessment.
As Bill Rogel said on the show, accepting an over-assessment for two, three or four more years because a reassessment is coming means overpaying the whole time. "If you're over-assessed now, appeal now. Solve the immediate problem in front of you."
Probably not much, and it is not supposed to. Nicole Hauptman Amick explained that the reassessment asks one question about every property: what is it worth today? Your current assessment is not the starting point for that answer.
Bill noted there may be some cases where a recent appeal decision is useful evidence, for example if the reassessment puts your value far above the market value set in an appeal a year earlier. But the main reason to appeal now is the money you save on each bill until new values take effect.
Most appeals have two levels. The first is a hearing before the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review (BPAAR), currently held by phone. The Board mails its decision, and either side then has 30 days to appeal to the Board of Viewers, part of the Court of Common Pleas, where a hearing officer hears the case more formally. Nicole estimates that 80 to 90% of her cases go through both levels, and the process can take years to fully resolve. How a property tax appeal works, step by step →
So what does a client have to do? On the podcast, Noah asked Nicole that exact question. Her answer: "Nothing." She handles the filings, the hearings and the negotiations, keeps clients updated, and talks with them when there is a decision or a settlement offer to consider.
If you have an appraisal for any reason, such as a purchase or refinance, keep it. It usually includes a sketch and measurements of your home, which can help correct square-footage errors in the County's records. It also gives you a baseline to compare against your new value when it arrives.
Not sure whether an appeal makes sense? We offer a free Pre-Reassessment Check-Up and will tell you plainly if an appeal is not worth it. Call 412-802-6666 or email nicole@pghfirm.com.
Listen to the full conversation on I Strenuously Object. Read our Allegheny County Reassessment Guide for the full timeline. General information only, not legal advice. Reassessment details may change as the County and the court act; confirm current deadlines.
