Your assessment may double, or more, when Allegheny County's new values arrive. That does not mean your tax bill will double. On a recent episode of our podcast, I Strenuously Object, attorneys Nicole Hauptman Amick, Bill Rogel and Noah Fardo talked through what the court-ordered reassessment is likely to mean for homeowners. Here is the plain-English version.
When the court ordered the reassessment in August 2026, Nicole's phone lit up with owners asking what would happen to their value next year. The answer: nothing yet. The County has until June 30, 2032, to put new values in place, although it may finish sooner. Until then, every tax bill uses your current assessment. See the full reassessment timeline →
Every property in Allegheny County is still assessed as if it were 2012. As Bill put it on the show, the County is playing a "game of make-believe": it freezes values in 2012 and uses a number called the Common Level Ratio (CLR) to convert today's market value back into 2012 dollars.
For tax year 2027 appeals, the CLR is 49.3%. In plain terms, the system treats a property's assessment as roughly half of what it would sell for today. Nicole's example: buy a house today for $1,000,000, and the appropriate assessment under the current system would be about $493,000.
A reassessment ends the make-believe. New values are meant to reflect current market value. So:
Pennsylvania has anti-windfall rules for exactly this situation. After a countywide reassessment, the County, your municipality and your school district must each lower their tax rates (millage) so that the reassessment itself does not hand them a windfall. The County and municipalities may then raise their total property tax revenue by no more than 5%, and only by a separate vote. School districts remain subject to the state's Act 1 limits.
Those caps apply to each taxing body's total revenue, not to your property. There is no cap on how much an individual assessment can rise, and an individual tax bill can rise by much more than 5%. As Bill pointed out, the total stays close to where it was, but individual bills will shift:
Our attorneys agreed it is a very hard job. About 585,000 properties have to be revalued, and Pittsburgh neighborhoods can differ sharply in value from one street to the next. Nicole recalled that after the 2012 reassessment, roughly one in six property owners filed an appeal. Expect mistakes this time too, and plan to check your new value carefully when it arrives.
Want a second opinion on your assessment? We offer a free Pre-Reassessment Check-Up. Call 412-802-6666 or email nicole@pghfirm.com.
Listen to the full conversation on I Strenuously Object. General information only, not legal advice. Reassessment details may change as the County and the court act; confirm current deadlines.
